News

The Buzz: Save Historic Jackson Hole excluded from Old Bill’s

Wednesday, July 23, 2008

By Ben Cannon

Jackson Hole, Wyo.-Valley preservationist group Save Historic Jackson Hole announced this week that it has been excluded from the 2008 Old Bill’s Fun Run, a banner fundraising event for many of the community’s nonprofits.

In mid-June, the Community Foundation of Jackson Hole, which organizes Old Bill’s, sent a letter to SHJH Board President Louis Wang, informing him that the foundation’s board of directors had “voted to deny” the conservative watchdog’s application for participation in the event. The board cited an April ad taken out by SHJH in the Jackson Hole News & Guide that questioned the “objectivity and credibility” of another Old Bill’s participant, the Jackson Hole Community Housing Trust.

At that time, the nonprofit Housing Trust was partnered with a private developer on Teton Meadows Ranch, a controversial proposal to build 500 homes in South Park. That project was put on ice, perhaps for good, after county commissioners imposed a moratorium in early May.

The ad was headed in bold letters with, “Follow the Money,” and suggested that the Housing Trust had “lost their way.” The ad’s content questioned whether the private nonprofit had “sold out to a crafty developer.”

The ad claimed the Housing Trust would collect $2 million “initially and hundreds of thousands of dollars per year in perpetuity” from a transfer tax.
Citing the disparaging nature of the ad, the Community Foundation board voted to exclude SHJH from this year’s Old Bill’s, set for September 13.

“It’s tone was not in keeping with the spirit of Old Bill’s, which we think is one of collaboration, cooperation and immense good will,” Katherine Conover, president of the Community Foundation, said this week.

SHJH President Louis Wang said the group was counting on the event to help fill its coffers and that the group had already contacted potential donors, informing them that the organization was registered for the fundraising event.
“We have some egg on our face,” Wang said.

Wang said he asked for an opportunity to meet with the Community Foundation board, but said his request fell on deaf ears.

“Without an explanation, the Community Foundation would be taking a stance that is unsupported by reason or logic and is injurious to Save Historic Jackson Hole,” Wang wrote in a July 7 letter to Conover and Community Foundation Vice Chair Bill Weiss.
The Community Foundation and the Housing Trust boards are chaired by the same person, Jim Moses, who, according to Conover, recused himself from the vote to exclude SHJH.

“Anyone else who had a perceived conflict either did not attend the meeting or did not vote,” Conover said.

Moses was not immediately available for comment Tuesday.
SHJH has not backed away from the ad.
“When millions of dollars change hands in conjunction with an endorsement, it needs to be reported,” Wang said in a phone interview Tuesday. He was out of state attending a seminar by the Dalai Lama.

The Housing Trust did not immediately return phone calls Tuesday.
In years prior, the Community Foundation board has voted to disallow Right to Life and Planned Parenthood from Old Bill’s participation, according to Conover.
“The board decided the issue of abortion was too divisive,” she said.

About 200 groups are currently registered to participate in this year’s Old Bill’s, during which time donors of means large and small can give to a number of area non-profits through a single donation to the Community Foundation. Conover described the event as “a very efficient - even elegant - process.”

The 2007 Old Bill’s Fun Run raised more than $7.7 million for area non-profits.
PERMALINK:
The Buzz: Save Historic Jackson Hole excluded from Old Bill’s | Planet JH News Article: General News

Reader Comments

freedom of speech? that's a load of bull. sounds like old bill had something to gain in the ranch development
gabe bobsom

Congratulations to Old Bills for having the backbone to boot shjh. The housing trust does honorable work. shjh is a special interest group that represents no one I know in my 30 years here. What a waste of charitable dollars if it were given to a fringe group such as shjh.
k

gabe- this is not a freedom of speech issue. SHJH is nothing more then a glorified PAC and any organization based solely on political motives should be disallowed.
steve h

K and Steve - it is absolutely a free speech issue. During the Teton Meadows debate the Housing Trust misrepresented the facts, backed email blogs that marginalized the oppositon as "fear mongering NIMBY's" and now they are using their political will (helps when the board chair is the same at both the Trust and Foundation) to intimadate the Foundation into censorship. Shame on the Housing Trust.
Watchdogs Rneeded

Save Historic Jackson Hole will gain more cred with me when they tear down their Kelly mansions that are right in the middle of the blessed migratory corridors we hear so much about. Let's be honest - which historic Jackson Hole are you talking about? The one that belonged to the natives? Or the elk and the buffalo? Or the one you bought into when you got here? Look at the number of condos on the market - the younger middle class is selling and getting out. My prediction - JH will be a valley full of billionaire second home owners and a permanent underclass of Mexicans and transient Eastern Europeans here to supply labor. The people that provide the character and soul of this community will be gone.
Good Luck

Give me a break. If we're booting nonprofits for building in migratory corridors, better get rid of Teton Science Schools for their new school location. Oh yah, certain nonprofits can do whatever they want in the name of "science" and "conservation" even when they destroy the land they're given to safeguard. The point is that Old Bill's can eliminate whatever nonprofit they want, whenever they want, so soak up the cash while you can. The unbiased nature of Old Bill's has faded. Now it's just run by a board of imported east coast liberals.
s

What nonprofit doesn't engage in politics to do their job? Schools do (at the local and state level); the arts have to (local, state and federal); pathways does (they do a lot of lobbying at the congressional level). And we know the Housing Trust does -- they were the primary lobbyist for TMR. Start making community-level decisions of who is a "deserving" nonprofit based on politics, and you have just opened a can of worms that does more harm than good. K&S, You may like the decision to kick out a group when it's one you don't like, but if the other writers in this blog were the decision makers and ousted the Housing Trust for their politics, then you might feel differently. I feel lucky to live in a country where free speech and differing opinions are tolerated. I hope that my town continues to live by the same.
What if the tables were turned?



Leave a Comment


Saturday, September 06, 2008

Partly Cloudy

55°

TODAY'S EVENTS
Sports & Recreation
Open Gym (Adults Only)
10:00 AM to 1:00 PM
in the Recreation Center Gym.
Sports & Recreation
Open Swim
1:00 PM to 9:00 PM
in the Recreation Center Gym.
Music
DJ Optimal every Saturday at
10:00 PM
at Cutty's.
Music
Phil Round performs
6:30 PM to 9:30 PM
in the double fireplace lobby of the Amangani Hotel atop East Gros Ventre Butte.
Outlying
Alpine Farmers Market
10:30 AM to 3:00 PM
at Tavern on the Greys RV Park just south of Alpine Junction.
Community
Jackson Hole Farmers Market
8:00 AM
on and around the Town Square.
Sports & Recreation
Open Gym
1:00 PM to 9:00 PM
in the Recreation Center Gym.
Art
Weekly Art & Crafts Fair
9:00 AM to 5:00 PM
on the banks of Fish Creek in Wilson.
Music
Bruce Howser & The Teton Allstars play
9:00 PM
at the Virginian Saloon.
Music
Nathan Dean plays country at
9:00 PM
at the Million Dollar Cowboy Bar.
Theater
"All in the Timing"
8:00 PM
in the Studio Theater at the Center for the Arts.
Music
Revolver plays rock n' roll
8:00 PM to 11:30 PM
at the Silver Dollar Bar in the Wort Hotel.
Community
Habitat for Humanity welcomes volunteers
at the Build Site.
Outdoors
Sierra Club Day Hike
up Paintbrush Canyon to Holly Lake.
Outdoors
Writer & Artist Outing
to the Mount Leidy Highlands.
Community
Memory Walk
8:00 AM
at River Rock Lodge in Rafter J.
Sports & Recreation
St. John's Golf Tournament
8:00 AM to 5:00 PM
at Jackson Hole Golf & Tennis.
Art
Western Design Conference Exhibition
10:00 AM to 5:00 PM
in the Pavilion at Snow King Center.
Art
Teton Wildlife & Western Arts Show
10:00 AM to 7:00 PM
at Snow King Resort.
Kids & Families
Saturday Storytime
10:30 AM to 11:00 AM
in the Storytime Room at the Library.
Community
Addie’s Benefit Trunk Show & Sale
11:00 AM to 5:00 PM
in the Lobby at the Center for the Arts.
Art
First Sunday
1:00 PM to 5:00 PM
at the National Museum of Wildlife Art.
Theater
"All in the Timing" Matinee
2:00 PM
in the Studio Theater at the Center for the Arts.
Music
Big Band USO-Style Show and Dinner
5:00 PM
in the Ballroom at the Virginian Convention Center.
Music
Pianist Keith Phillips solos
7:00 PM to 10:00 PM
in the Granary at Spring Creek Ranch atop East Gros Ventre Butte.
Music
Dark Cheddar jams rock, funk and reggae
10:00 PM
at 43 North.
Music
Dark Cheddar jams rock, funk and reggae
10:00 PM
at 43 North.
View All Events
YOUR BLOGS

9/3/2008 | 10:22 PM
Palin Phenomenal

9/1/2008 | 3:05 PM
Comprehensive DUI Bill

planet polls
Main Poll
Do you think Sarah Palin is a good VEEP choice for McCain?


Total of voters : 114